I’m A Liar
Nidhu Bhusan Das
I’m a liar, am I, really? This doubt
haunts me, often and anon. Monists would say, if not a liar, at least I’m a
stupid. They believe statements have literal meanings, and we need not have
doubt about it. I would have been happy had I been able to go by such a belief.
My personal experience is different. I cannot take it for granted that words
reveal the mind, sound may, sometimes, when it’s exclamation. Let me explain.
Once my buddy Dulu, now in Maryland,
USA in a chat message told me ,midway through the conversation,”Well,Nidhu,
I’ll return in a minute” and left. After
two days she sent me a mail which reads: “Nidhu, dear, never mind. My daughter
Roxana is back from New York
in vacation. She arrived when we’re in conversation. You know she’s so naughty,
and won’t allow me to share time with anyone else. So, I couldn’t return, as promised. Would you
mind, dear?” Could I, especially when we’re childhood pals and classmates till
university days? I replied,” No, dear, I couldn’t mind. Your silence has been
golden. Now, when you have told me of Roxana mom, can I but be gay? I could
understand you had become damn busy with something important. Dulu protested
against my statement, “Your silence was golden” and said vehemently that I was
ironical and critical of her going away promising to return in no time.
Dulu, as I know, and I’m, perhaps, the
right person to talk on her mental process, is mercurial. She would often pick
quarrel with me over trifles, scold me for minutes together, and then cry
throwing books at me. We had many intimate minutes as well, planning future
shared life. We quarreled and next minute caressed each other. Friends would
hurl oblique remarks, and we would not mind.
She has been equivocal- what she says
yields meanings enough to hide her intention, and smiles when I fail to
comprehend what she actually means. Even when I guess the meaning correctly,
she misleads me saying ‘No. I have not intended this. What I mean is………’
Really, it’s difficult, I should say impossible, to win against her, she is so
naughty. I’m not at all ironical when I say silence is golden, but I must not
contradict her because she will, in that case, stop talking to me, which I
cannot bear. I don’t lie, yet when it comes to my relation with Dulu, accept
I’m a liar, and it’s for peace and to be together even when we’re apart.